I had a problem with my PayPal account: I used it in China, and it got blocked as the result of some kind of fraud screening.
I ended up having to promise the guys at Bike Beijing that I will sort this out when I get back to the UK and then send them their money.
[FromÂ Digital Money: Holding court]
They still havenâ€™t got their money. In order to unblock the account, you had to log in to your account and then have a code sent via your home telephone number. I clicked, the phone rang, I punched in the number and hung up. Nothing. I clicked again, the phone rang, I punched in the number and waited. Nothing. I clicked again, the phone rang, I punched in the number. After a while, I got an e-mail telling me that the authentication process had failed and so PayPal would send a letter containing some kind of code to my home address and that I could then use this code to unblock my account. It mentioned that the letter might takes six weeks to arrive.
So the nice guys atÂ Bike Beijing still donâ€™t have their money and Iâ€™m still embarrassed.
Now, all the time that this nonsense about codes and letters was going on, I had on my desk a Barclaysâ€™ PINSentry (which I canâ€™t even use to log on to Barclaycard, let alone PayPal) and a O2 mobile phone (Iâ€™ve been with O2 for two decades and have a billing relationship with them – their systemÂ knew that I was in China) and a keyring OTP generator that we used for our corporate VPN. Any one of these could provide a better solution then messing about typing in code numbers, but they all sit in their own silos and donâ€™t provide the kind of general-purpose services that they should.
What should have happened, of course, is that I should have been able to log in to PayPal using OpenID and then logged in to a 2FA OpenID using my (say) PINSentry. So now PayPal knows that I have been 2FA logged in from an â€śacceptableâ€ť source (ie, Barclays Bank) and we could move on. So why doesnâ€™t this happen? Is it because OpenID has failed?
But if OpenID is a failure, itâ€™s one of the webâ€™s most successful failures. OpenID is available on more than 50,000 websites. There are over a billion OpenID enabled URLs on the web thanks to providers like Google, Yahoo and AOL. Yet, for most people, trying to log in to every website using OpenID remains a difficult task, which means that while thousands of websites support it, hardly anyone uses OpenID.
It canâ€™t be that. OpenID has plenty of support, and even the US government got behind it.
Who would have predicted say, 5 years ago, that you would some day be able to use commercial identities on government websites? Evidently, this raises questions about privacy and security but if these initiatives can garner enough public support, government validation of open identity frameworks could be a boon for the ecosystem of the open, distributed web. Plus, it can make dealing with the government a lot easier for you, too.
Itâ€™s not about the technology. I make no judgement as to whether OpenID is the best technology or not (although it does actually exist, which is a good start), but the truth is that it simply doesnâ€™t matter whether it is or it isnâ€™t.
The unresolved business and legal challenges implicit in federated identity are to blame for the under-delivery of OpenID
Indeed they are. So the problem isnâ€™t really anything to do with OpenID, or any other framework that might come along in cyberspace, but the legal framework that it has to sit inside. This is where we need the breakthrough. We need potential identity providers (eg, Barclays, O2) to be able to set up OpenID responders for their customers inside a well-known and well-understood legal framework. Now, you can do this contractually (asÂ IdenTrust has done), but to scale to the open web, we need something more than that, perhaps an equivalent of the â€ścreative commonsâ€ť licences that are used for content but for credentials.
Even then, would someone like PayPal rely on them? Or would it only rely on identities from regulated financial institutions in the EU? Or only such institutions that met some minimum authentication standard? Weâ€™re a long way from fixing my Chinese problem, despite having all of the technology needed to do so.
These are personal opinions and should not be misunderstood as representing the opinions of
Consult Hyperion or any of its clients or suppliers
These are the personal opinions of Consult Hyperion and its guests and should not be misunderstood as representing the opinion of its clients or suppliers. To discuss how any of the technologies discussed in this post can benefit your business, please contact Consult Hyperion.