[Dave Birch] As I’ve constantly complained, what should one do if one is (broadly speaking) in favour of some form of smart identity card to bridge the worlds of physical and virtual identity, but one is (broadly speaking) against the government’s proposed system? Well, one policy might be to stop reading the newspapers and hope it will all get better. Consider, for example, the Department of Work and Pensions’ attempt to salvage a viable system from the Child Support Agency catastrophe, the Child Maintenance and Enforcement Commission (CMEC), which adds several sticks to beat recalcitrant parents with. There is going to be a ‘name and shame’ web site, credit blacklisting, monitored curfews (possible including electronic tagging) and the confiscation of passport and/or ID card. That’s joined-up government at work, presumably. The Child Maintenance & Other Payments Bill includes powers for the CMEC to disqualify an individual from “holding or obtaining travel authorisation”, with a travel authorisation being defined as a UK passport or as “an ID card… that… has been issued to a British citizen.” This kind of predictable — and tragic (in the sense of inevitable) — mission creep is an consequence of an ill-thought out identity infrastructure that is not up to the demands of a modern society or modern economy. And even if you think that taking away some ID-related privilege is the right thing to do to a deadbeat Dad, the use of the word “confiscation” reveals the basic mindset problem: “they” won’t stop you from renewing a public key certificate, delete an application from the card, change a security level or anything else that might smack of the 21st century, “they” will confiscate the card. Hey, Parliament, I’ve got 1952 on the line and they want their ID card back…
Technorati Tags: ID cards, management
These are the personal opinions of Consult Hyperion and its guests and should not be misunderstood as representing the opinion of its clients or suppliers. To discuss how any of the technologies discussed in this post can benefit your business, please contact Consult Hyperion.